From: Todd G >I came across your post in which you said that the nature of what is >behind the watch face, i.e. the supreme being responsible for setting this >universe into motion, is completely unknowable to us. I realize I may be >paraphrasing your actual statement, forgive me please. >Could you tell me why you believe this to be true? > >Thanks, Todd I was referring to the scientists rather than the transcendentalists. For the scientists depend on a different process. One who believes in God can perceive His presence. God reveals Himself to His devotees. So they can see and experience the "supreme person who set this universe in motion." They can also have some knowledge from the scriptures as to what is beyond this universe... The scientists, however, only accept what they can see, hear, feel, touch and smell for themselves. They observe things and try to explain the observations with "scientific" theories. While this is certainly a process of acquiring knowledge, it is a very slow and imperfect one. All such "scientific" knowledge is always flawed because it is gathered by the scientists using their imperfect senses. All our senses are imperfect: we can't see things that are very close or far away, we can only see a limited range of frequencies... But that is not all. Everyone has a tendency to cheat. If I want to prove my theory I will accept the evidence that supports it, but I may not pay too much attention to observations that contradict it... We are also illusioned... We accept so many things as facts which are not facts at all. Science is full of "initial assumptions", and many of these may be wrong, so any theory which relies on these assumptions will also be wrong. If you are doing a big calculation and you make a mistake in the beginning, no matter how nice your calculations are after that point, the answer will be wrong... And finally we all make mistakes. So many experiments are performed but often there are mistakes and the results are not correct... This "scientific process" is the ascending process for acquiring knowledge. It means finding out things using our own power... But it is not a very perfect method as I have described above. The other way to get knowledge is via the descending process. That means to find a perfect authority, someone who knows, and just accept the knowledge from him. It is not an unfamiliar process. If you want to become a carpenter you go to a carpenter and ask him to take you on as his apprentice... This is the best way to learn. So we just accept the knowledge Krishna has given in the Vedic scriptures in India. There are thousands of Vedic scriptures on every topic, material and spiritual. There is the Auya-veda for medicine, the Danna-veda for the science of fighting and war, there is the Joyti-veda for astronomy and astrology, there are Vedic scriptures for everything... There are also Vedic scriptures describing the universe and what is beyond the universe, the spiritual sky. The bona fide spiritual master simply presents this Vedic knowledge. He doesn't inject his own ideas or philosophy. So the knowledge a bona fide spiritual master presents is perfect. He can tell you all about the supreme person who is responsible for setting this universe in motion. But such bona fide spiritual masters are rare. There are many charlatans presenting themselves as "bona fide spiritual masters" for fame, money, to attract followers, etc... So this has put a lot of people off. But still if we want to find the truth we have to find a real guru... tad viddhi pranipatena pariprasnena sevaya upadeksyanti te jnanam jnaninas tatt va-darsinah "Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized souls can impart knowledge unto you because they have seen the truth." (Bhagavad-gita 4.34) There are so many things, even in this universe, that the scientists can not see so how can they ever understand them? The only way is to find an authority and get the knowledge in that way. Scientists can't even get complete knowledge of the universe, they certainly have absolutely no ability to find out what is beyond the universe...