Published on December 1st, 2023 | by HDG A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada


Life On Other Planets [MP3 Audio]

Here is a puzzle for the rascal scientists–they are contemplating that except within this earth, there is no life. Take for example the sun planet. Naturally, we imagine no living entity can live there: it is a fiery planet. But Krsna says I first of all spoke this Bhagavad-gita system to the sun-god. Now rascals will think How is there a god or a person in the sun planet? Everything from


nainam chindanti sastrani
nainam dahati pavakah
na cainam kledayanty apo
na sosayati marutah

“The soul can never be cut into pieces by any weapon, nor can he be burned by fire, nor moistened by water, nor withered by the wind.”

So here is another puzzle for the rascal scientists–because they are contemplating that except within this earth, in other planets, there is no life. Because the atmosphere is different, they cannot live there. Now, take for example the sun planet, fiery planet. So naturally, we shall imagine that no living entity can live there: it is fiery planet. But Krishna says that nainam dahati pavakah. The fire does not burn it. This is quite reasonable because the living entities are there, we can experience. Roughly we see that we are on the land and the aquatics, fishes, they are in the water. I cannot live within the water, neither the fish cannot live on the land, but from my experience, if we think that there is no living entities in water, is it not rascaldom? Similarly, these rascals are thinking from his own point of view. Because he cannot live within the fire or within the water, he’s thinking there is no life within the fire. This is rascaldom. To refute these rascals, Krsna says, nainam dahati pavakah. Even within the fire there are living entities. Therefore Krsna says imam vivasvate yogam proktavan aham avyayam. “I spoke first of all this Bhagavad-gita system to the sun-god.”

Now rascals will think that “How there is a god or there is a person in the sun planet?” They’ll think like that. Everything from his own angle of vision. This is modern science. “I cannot think of such thing. Therefore, there cannot be any such thing.” Just like everything should be within my experience. This is going on. They never admit that “What is your experience?” You are imperfect, your senses are imperfect, how you can be perfectly experienced? It is not possible. Acintya. There are so many inconceivable powers acting on behalf of Krsna. What are you? You may cheat some people that you have become God. That is another thing. But the inconceivable potency of Krsna, they are working differently. Srila Jiva Gosvami says that unless we accept this principle that Krsna or God has got inconceivable power, acintya-sakti, we cannot understand. If we put Krsna within the jurisdiction of my limited understanding, that is not understanding of Krsna. Manusyanam sahasresu kascid yatati siddhaye.

That inconceivable power is also within us. We do not know. So many things are happening. The example, as I gave many times, that the one nail was taken off. Still, it grew exactly to the size of the nail. In my personal body, in the nails. So the doctors cannot make exactly fitting nail, but it is growing exactly to the size. Even it is inconceivable to me how it is growing. Even my hair grows inconceivable, I do not know. I cut every week, and it still grows. There are so many little inconceivable power within me. I am part and parcel of God. Just imagine how much inconceivable power is there in Krsna. It is common sense.

We understand from the sastras that Krsna, as Garbhodakasayi Visnu, He created water within this universe and lie down, Garbhodakasayi Visnu. Now we cannot conceive that how a person can produce water from the body like the sea and ocean. But if you think over little soberly, that sometimes we perspire, we get perspiration. That is water. In India, we have got special experience during summer season. Sometimes a small pot can be filled up with the water produced from my body like this, put. Of course, one must be healthy man. Then he’ll perspire and water will come out from the body. So I am limited. I am only a small particle of Krsna’s body, part and parcel. If I have got this power of producing water, maybe one grain or two grain or one ounce; Krsna has got unlimited power, why not a sea? Where is the difficulty to understand? He can produce unlimited quantity of water which may be known as ocean and sea. Yato va imani bhutani jayante. Therefore, Vedas say that “From whom all these five elements have come into being?” And Krsna says,

bhumir apo ‘nalo vayuh
kham mano buddhir eva ca
ahankara itiyam me
bhinna prakrtir astadha

“That is my energy.” So everything is Krsna’s energy. He can produce. Try to verify from the example. Because you are little sample of Krsna. You can study what you are doing, what you are feeling, what you are acting. The same thing in unlimited quantity, Krsna has got the power. That’s all.

So here it is said, Arjuna might be thinking that “Krsna says this body is different from the soul. The soul is within. So now suppose when I place my sword on the body of my grandfather or my kinsmen, the body will cut, and, in the meantime, the soul is within the body. It may be cut because the soul is there. By accidentally, he may be cut.” Therefore Krsna says very distinctly; nainam chindanti sastrani, that “Soul cannot be cut. Any weapon. It cannot be pierced by your arrows, it cannot be cut into pieces by your sword, or if you use firearms it will not burn.” Nainam dahati pavakah. This is the position of soul. Immutable, indestructible. Another… This is the negative description of the soul. Nainam chindanti sastrani. Is there anything in this material world which cannot be cut into pieces? Have you got any experience? Take wood, stone, iron, or anything. It can be cut into pieces. Therefore, the…, when Krsna says nainam chindanti sastrani, that means it is nothing like anything material elements. It is different. It is different. Any material elements. There are earth, water, fire, air, and ether. You can prepare weapons from earth. Water, you cannot do now. But there can be a weapon from the water also. That was used in the Battle of Kuruksetra. Here, the atomic bomb is thrown, brahmastra. From the other side the watery astra is thrown so that the energy of the atomic bomb is immediately finished. So what the scientists know now? Although they have manufactured atomic bomb, but they are unable to manufacture another weapon counteraction of atomic bomb. That is not possible. But there is. Atomic bomb is fiery, and if you manufacture another bomb which is watery, then you can counteract. Because fight means I charge you with some kind of weapon. You have to protect yourself by the counteraction. That was going on. So nainam chindanti sastrani nainam dahati pavakah.

So it is quite natural to understand that if there is living entity within the earth, within the water, even in the air… That we experience. In the air there are so many living entities. In the water, unvisible, not seen by the naked eyes. By microscope, we can see so many germs are there in the water, in the air. So why not in the fire? Fire is also one of the material elements. Therefore, the sun planet, although it is fiery planet, there is inhabitation of different type of human being who may be called as demigods. But there are similar buildings, similar persons, cities, motorcars, everything. Everything is there. Otherwise, how Krsna could go there and says that imam vivasvate yogam proktavan aham avyayam, unless it is exactly a planet like this where living entities, houses, roads, cars and everything is there? As Krsna advented Himself within this planet, He came here, Krsna can go anywhere. Krsna, when He was present, He was going anywhere. Sometimes within the waters, sometimes within the walls of the universe, sometimes in the spiritual world. He went to the spiritual world, taking Arjuna with Him. Arjuna also went with Him. And He saw the Karanodakasayi Visnu in the spiritual world. These things are there, described in the Srimad-Bhagavatam. He could go anywhere. They were going to the heavenly planets. That is Krsna. Not Guruji. (laughs) That one slap, and he’s blind. Not like that. Krsna could go, Krsna can do… All, this is called omnipotent, all-powerful. So unless we think of Krsna possessing unconceivable powers, we cannot understand Krsna.

Nainam chindanti sastrani nainam dahati pavakah. Another study from this verse is that the Mayavada philosophy, they say that spirit is one. The Supreme Spirit, impersonal. When the spirit is embodied, it becomes individual. This is their philosophy. Otherwise, they give the example… Just like there is water on the sea. It is also sustained on the earth. A big mass of water. And on that water, you can put one boat or ship full of water. And on that boat, you put another, a cup of water, and in the cup of water, you put another pot, a small cup or small utensil or even the skin of a grain, that will also contain. So their philosophy is that the water is one, but according to the pot or container, it becomes small and big. This is their philosophy. And when the container is broken, then the whole water becomes one. This is their philosophy. Now this nonsense philosophy is refuted in this verse. How? Now because spirit, either you take whole spirit or part spirit, nainam chindanti sastrani. You cannot divide it by cutting into pieces. That is not possible. So their philosophy is that the water has been put into different pots, therefore we see this small water, this smaller or bigger, this division. But they are all individual always.

It is not that it has been divided. Mamaivamso jiva-bhutah jiva-loke sanatanah. Sanatana. Sanatana means eternally they are divided. It is not that it has been divided by some means. Just like we keep water in big pot or small pot. That is not possible. They are big or small eternally. Visnu-tattva, jiva-tattva. The jiva-tattva, they are small fragments. They are eternal. Visnu-tattva. Visnu-tattva means the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Visnu-tattva is unlimitedly great eternally, sanatana. And the jiva-tattva, they are infinitesimally smaller eternally. Not that it has been cut into small and big. No.

So this Mayavadi theory cannot stand here if we accept the Bhagavad-gita’s statement. Nainam chindanti sastrani. It is not divided by some means. No. It is already divided. It is already divided. Neither the small piece of soul or the big piece of soul you can divide.

nainam chindanti sastrani
nainam dahati pavakah
na cainam kledayanty apo
na sosayati marutah

Air… There are earth, water, fire, air. So none of these material things can act on the soul. It is not that because air dries up everything, anything… Big, big ocean is dried up by evaporation. Big, big river, big, big lakes are evaporated, but soul cannot be evaporated. Nainam sosayati marutah. This is the distinction. The air can evaporate a big ocean.

Gradually, it is being done. As the days will go on, the sea water will be evaporated, and at the end there will be no water. These are the statements. Towards destruction, there will be no water. Just like now it is already begun. There is scarcity of water, no rainfall. So we see that the lakes and rivers and other water reservoirs, they are becoming dried up. Syamasundara, you were telling that river? What is that lake?

Syamasundara: Reservoir.

Prabhupada: Drying up. So there must be dry up and there must be supply. Nature’s way. That is the way. But in the, with the advancement of Kali-yuga, there will be scarcity of supply, but the water will dry up gradually. The result will be there will be no water. As there will be no water, everything, all living entities, vegetation, living being, everything will finish, will die. For hundreds of years there will be no water, and then when everything is finished, dried up, burned into ashes due to and the sunshine, the glare of the sunshine will be twelve times increased and there will be no water. How one can live? So everything on this planet will be finished. And then, being warmer, warmer, there will be fire. In the fire, all planets of the universe will be burned into ashes. Then there will be rainfall. Another. For hundred years. So the whole universe will be filled up with water. Then it will be evaporated, and the whole universe, cosmic manifestation finished. This is called annihilation. So in Bhagavad-gita there is a statement that when everything is annihilated, the spiritual world is not annihilated. Na vinasyasi. So as the spiritual world does not annihilate, similarly the soul, the spirit, by any such disturbances, the soul is never annihilated. Avyayam indestructible, immutable. So Krsna is explaining in different ways the nature of the soul. We have to take it seriously, then we get perfect knowledge.

So, next verse you can…

acchedyo ‘yam adahyo ‘yam
akledyo ‘sosya eva ca
nityah sarva-gatah sthanur
acalo ‘yam sanatanah

“This individual soul is unbreakable and insoluble, and can be neither burned nor dried. He is everlasting, all-pervading, unchangeable, immovable and eternally the same.”

So this is another way, negative way. In the previous verse Krsna says: nainam chindanti sastrani. And now, negatively or passively, it is said that acchedyo ‘yam. In every way, Krsna is suggesting the immortality of the soul. There are five elements: earth, water, fire, air. So none of these elements can act on the soul. You can prepare sword, cutting sword from earth, from metal, but it does not mean that you can cut anything material with your sword. But you cannot cut the spirit soul with your sword or with your other material weapons. Neither… Acchedyo ‘yam adahyah. Neither you can burn with fire, neither you can moisten it with water, neither you can dry. In every respect Krsna explains how soul is immutable. Another significance is nityah sarva-gatah. Sarva-gatah means all-pervading, everywhere the soul is there. Even within the stone, even within the sands, there are. So how these people can say there is no existence of living entity in the moon planet? Sarva-gatah. We have seen sometimes that from the stone, I have marked it. There is one juma mastika(?) in Agra. On the top of the stone dome a plant has come out, on the top. Now who has gone to place that seed that a banyan tree, banyan plant has come out and it has cracked the stone? So nobody has gone there, but this means the soul is everywhere. As soon as it gets the opportunity, it accepts a material body immediately. As soon as there is opportunity. That is explained in the Seventh Chapter very nicely. (break)

…planetary system, say moon planet or other planet. They also again come down on this earthly planet. Ksine… (break) … Just like you get visa for going to a foreign country. As soon as the visa period is over, the visa department immediately reminds you: “Sir, your visa is finished. Now you must go. You must go out.” So the whole, the punya-loka, the higher planetary system, svarga-loka, you can go there by your pious activities, by performing big, big yajnas, punya, pious activities, go there. But ksine punye martya-lokam visanti. When your punya, it is also limited thing, when it is finished, you have to come back. It is said that when they come back on this planet they come through the water, showers, and they fall down on this earth. Again they begin their life as grass and something like that, evolution. Ksine punye martya-lokam visanti. Therefore this elevation to the higher planetary system, Krsna condemns them. Abrahma-bhuvanal lokah punar avartino ‘rjuna. “My dear Arjuna, even if you go to the higher planetary system, Brahmaloka, to live for many millions of years, still when your asset of pious activity will be finished, you’ll have to come back here.” But He again said, mad-dhama gatva punar janma na vidyate, that “If you try to come back to My place, then you’ll not come back.”

So the karmis, karma-kandiya, they are trying to be elevated to the heavenly planet, higher planetary system. That is not very good idea. You can go to the higher planetary system by your pious activities. First of all the modern age, the people are so much impious, sinful, that is not also possible. They may go down. Jaghanya-guna-vrtti-stha adho gacchanti tamasah. They are covered with ignorance. The ignorance is wine, women, and meat-eating. So they are going down. There is no possibility of going higher planetary system, not possible. Who will go to the higher planetary system? Urdhvam gacchanti sattva-sthah. Urdhvam means higher. Only those who are pious, they can be elevated. So even if you are pious, still you have to come back again. This is the process. So sarva-gatah. Sarva-gatah means a soul is free to go anywhere, anywhere. Full freedom, as he wants. That is also explained in the Bhagavad-gita:

yanti deva-vrata devan
pitrn yanti pitr-vratah
bhutani yanti bhutejya
yanti mad-yajino ‘pi mam

As you like. It is up to you. Make your selection where you want to be. You have, somehow or other, you have come here. That’s all right. But Krsna gives you chance to be elevated to any planetary system you like. Ultimately, if you want to go back to home, back to Godhead, that is also given, everything. Mad-yajino ‘pi yanti mam. So if you want to go to the moon planet, there is no need of the sputnik. There is a process so that after this body you become elevated to the moon planet. Why should you make research for, and futile research, going to the moon? You just prepare yourself. There are different processes. If you want to go to the moon planet, you can go. If you want to go to the heavenly planet, you can go. Similarly, if you want to go to the planet where Krsna is, you can go. So sane man, intelligent man, should consider that “If I have to prepare myself for going, for being elevated to the higher planetary system, but we have to come back again, ksine punye martya-loka, why not endeavor for going back to Krsnaloka?” That is intelligence. But there are big, big yogis, they elevate themselves to the higher planetary system. They… Before going to the spiritual world, they want to see how the higher planetary system are working. Just like the visitors, tourists. They are going somewhere, and drop, by journey, somewhere to see. But you should not make such ambition. You should endeavor directly going back to home, back to Godhead, Krsna. That should be your endeavor. Yes. Mad-yajino ‘pi yanti mam.

And the process is very simple. Yajinah, just worshiping Krsna as we have introduced. This mangala-aratrika, this offering food, worshiping. Mad-yajinah. Man-mana bhava mad-bhakto mad-yaji mam namaskuru, yaji. Yajana means worship. So what is the difficulty? If, by this simple process, tyaktva deham punar janma naiti mam eti, you can go back to Krsna, why we shall try for going to the heavenly planet, moon planet, this planet, where again we have to come from. Ksine punye martya-lokam. This is intelligence.

Thank you very much. (end)

730827BG.LON Bhagavad-gita 2.23-24 London, August 27, 1973

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada

Tags: , ,

About the Author

Founded the Hare Krishna Movement in 1966 in New York. In only 11 years he spread the movement all over the world. He wrote more than 80 books including Bhagavad-gita As It Is, Srimad-Bhagavatam, Sri Caitanya-caritamrta, Sri Isopanisad. Prabhupada's books constitute a complete library of Vedic philosophy, religion, literature and culture.

13 Responses to Life On Other Planets [MP3 Audio]

  1. Prabuddha says:

    First one has to qualify for getting a Satguru after that one need not have to go any where to know the details of relative existence (life on other planets, various worlds, presiding deities, vedic devtas, various kinds of life forms, laws of karma, etc.) and Brahman (i.e.Absolute existence). A Satguru shows you all the above things by rousing the Kundalini power latent in everybody. This process is eternal (Guru- Shishya parampara) and knowledge gained is experienced and internalised by the disciple. Then there is now doubt and confusion about the trans-material existence of life. Further,this leads to transformation/expansion of your consciousness and you become a devotee. Srila Prabhupada has undergone this process, so he had taught all this things to everyone – a shiksha guru’s role. These things are written also in Srimad Bhagavatam, but none can start believing that holy scripture as well as Srila Prabhupadaji by reading or listening. To see is to know – that is the Vedic process of getting knowledge. And I don’t know whether Srila Prabhupada is a Satguru or not, but to qualifying for “seeing” one has to follow him(without questioning his intention or achievement) and do what he has asked everyone to do. If you don’t have faith in him , you choose your other shiksha guru and follow him. In that way you will be able to qualify for the real knowledge and your goal will be achieved.

    Science deals with finite things, while spirituality deals with infinite. And infinite is beyond intellect (indeterminate), so basic rule of spirituality is to abstain from discussion before the transformation of your material consciousness. And there is no need of discussion ones you experience the reality!

    Hope this makes sense.

  2. I just wanted to say All glories to Srila Prabhupada!!! Thank you.

  3. […] hvor verden ser anderledes ud. For eksempel i Bhagavad Gita, som blandt andet beskriver et univers sydende af liv, modsat den stadige melding om et nedfrosset univers med håb om en bakterie hist og pist, der […]

  4. Sam says:

    Dear Site Administrator,

    I believe that these divine lectures/discourses are not worthy to be subjected for comments or discussion as they are spoken by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhuapda (a well recognized ‘Mahajana’). These lectures and deliverences may remain beyond the level of understandings of many common souls of the materialistic society. It may unnecessarily invite disgrace to the holy discourses. Thanks.

    • SanatKumar says:

      listen sam, Dont say that kind of stuffs. Cause people who dont understand these things cannot comment like Bhabesh or Rohini. Read their comments first and then dare to comment the way you did.

      And of course there should be provision of commenting and discussing for all kind of people. DO yuu thing God and His related discussions are for only the educated fools like you??

  5. Bhavesh says:


    This article is very interesting. I am a firm believer in the almighty God( not necessarily Krishna). The reason I say ”NOT necessarily Krishna” is because as we know there are people out there who beleive in for example, Rama, Shirdi Sai Baba, Swaminarayan, Buddha, etc and NOT believe in Krishna. According to Sri Madhuvisa Dasa and His Guru it seems to me that they are completely rejecting the material world which is a bit contradictory to what they are saying about Krishna. Let me explain, they say that Krishna has created the entire universe from atoms to galaxies including people who in turn have created the physical things like computers, cars, etc so the knowledge of creating physical things comes indirecly or directly from Krishna then Sri Madhuvisa Dasa and his Guru should also accept the material world as it comes ultimately from the supreme being ie Krishna. It is not correct to say that we should avoid the material world and completely dedicate our lives to Krishna. The Supreme Being is all encompasing and He does not need us to complete dedicate our lives to Him. It does not matter to Him whether we wholeheartedly surrender ourselves onto Him or not what he cares about is how we surrender ourselves in serving and helping the human society ie helping people in need, being good to everyone, not hurting anyone, etc. These good characteriestics will project us towards the Almighty. In some previous articles, Madhuvisa Dasa has compared us Humans as Hogs and Dogs and Foolish just because we work hard to fulfil our human needs- this is again not a good comparison. I know I have written this and it will not be published but anyways I am just expressing my views.

    • Hare Krishna Bavesh

      Neither I nor Srila Prabhupada have ever said that we should completely reject this material world. Rather as you say, we also say, this material world is the energy of Krishna and the energy of Krishna should be used in the service of Krishna. So our process is not at all to reject the material world but to utilize the material world and everything in it in the service of Krishna.

      Ad far as your hodge-podge ideas and your support of the philosophies of Sai Baba, Swaminarayan, Buddha, etc, these are all bogus philosophies. Even though Lord Buddha is an incarnation of Krishna, he appeared with a special mission to bewilder the atheists into worshiping him. So he presented a philosophy which was not actually correct but which was attractive to the atheists. So, although Buddha is an incarnation of Krishna, the philosophy he preaches is bogus. It is similar with Sankacharaya. He is an incarnation of Lord Shiva, but he preached basically Buddhism using the Vedas as the authority. So he has perverted the Vedas to support his concocted impersonal philosophy.

      The real truth is not easy to find.

      You can find it in the books of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada.

  6. Rohini says:

    You should not have used the word “rascal” over and over again. It sounds too shrill. I am extremely unhappy over your language selection. If scientists are too stupid, then why do you use computers? Weren’t these computers made by scientists? The God is needed for spiritual life and scientists are needed for practical life. Moreover, science is in progress; things impossible today may be possible tomorrow.

    Using foul language and insulting others to prove you are correct should be avoided. It serves no purpose.

    Hare Krsna !!

    • Hare Krsihna Rohini

      It is not me who is calling the people rascals, that is my spiritual master, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhuapda.

      Srila Prabhupada is using the right word to describe the materialists.

      If you look up ‘rascal’ in the dictionary you will find:

      1. a base, dishonest, or unscrupulous person.
      2. a mischievous person or animal: That child is a real rascal.

      So scientists are generally dishonest and unscrupulous, and also mischievous. These are qualities shared by all materialists.

      Computers are not actually made by scientists. This is the “age of Kali” or the age of machines. So the machines are naturally coming. They are coming because Krishna, who is present within the hearts of everyone, even within the hearts of the scientists, is giving the intelligence to the scientists how they can make these computers.

      Krishna is providing everything. The intelligence in the scientists and the raw materials that make the computers possible. There is something very wonderful in silicon that makes the computers possible. Without the silicon provided by Krishna the scientists can not make computers. Without the brain provided by Krishna they can not make computers, without the intelligence provided by Krishna they can not make computers.

      So the scientists are making computers only because Krishna is giving them the intelligence how to make them and the ingredients to make them with.

      Considering this the computers actually belong to Krishna. If I give a carpenter some wood and pay him for his work and he makes a chair from that wood the carpenter can not claim that this is his chair, he has worked to make it from the wood I gave him and I have paid him for his time so it is my chair.

      Similarly Krishna is providing everything to the scientists even their intelligence so when they make a computer the credit goes to Krishna.

      So the best use, the only legitimate use of the products produced by the scientists is to use them in the service of Krishna.

      We can use everything in the service of Krishna. We do not reject things that can be used in the service of Krishna.

      The scientists are rascals but when they produce something that can be used in the service of Krishna the devotees of Krishna will make full use of this. That is what these scientific gadgets are for, serving Krishna…

      Chant Hare Krishna and be happy.

      Madhudvisa dasa

      • SanatKumar says:

        Dear madhudvisa-dasa

        So i think its better if you use dishonest replacing Rascals to describe them so that we may not get confused.

        Hare Krishna

  7. satyajeet says:

    universe is infinite……..

  8. rajan says:

    All glories to srilaprabhupada,
    Hari bol prabhu.
    Suppose if we assume all this universe in the shape of a circle.And vedas say pramatma is everywhere.No human bieng has seen the whole universe till now & scientists say that size of universe is increasing so it means consciouness is also incresing in the extended part of cirlcle which changes the basic principal of vedas that supreme reality is unchangeable.Plz furnish my knowledge.
    Ur humble servant

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Back to Top ↑